WeedVoter
Texas

Judge, Court of Criminal Appeals, Place 9

Result of the 3 November 2026 election

Holly Taylor won, with 52.3% of the vote.

CandidatePartyVotesShare
Holly TaylorDemocrat5,043,09452.3%
John MessingerRepublican4,602,68147.7%

Unofficial count from the Texas Secretary of State, updated 4 November 2026, 4:59 p.m., with 100% of polling places reporting. Race call as reported by The Texas Tribune on the state courts. Results are final only after the state canvass.

Texas’s highest criminal court hears drug-possession and search-and-seizure appeals, so this race matters for cannabis even though no campaign is about it. Whether either candidate has previously served as a judge has not been verified here, so no claim is made about published opinions either way. The candidates’ silence here is required, not evasive. The Texas Code of Judicial Conduct, Canon 5(1)(i), says a judge or judicial candidate shall not "make pledges or promises of conduct in office regarding pending or impending cases, specific classes of cases, specific classes of litigants, or specific propositions of law that would suggest to a reasonable person that the judge is predisposed to a probable decision". Marijuana possession and hemp prosecutions are exactly such a class of cases before this court, so this site does not read a judicial candidate’s silence the way it reads a legislator’s. (Texas Code of Judicial Conduct: www.txcourts.gov/media/1462935/texas-state-code-of-judicial-conduct.pdf)

John MessingerRepublican

No score: the record below carries no direction this site is willing to score — an abstention, a vote on a bill whose effect on legal access is genuinely arguable, or a statement that names no position. It is shown in full so you can read it and judge for yourself.

  • Said2022-07-18

    Wrote and signed a model brief that his employer, the State Prosecuting Attorney's office, publishes for prosecutors to adapt, titled on that office's publications page "Model Brief on Hemp Versus Marijuana Smell for Probable Cause to Search a Vehicle Following Texas Hemp Farmgrower's Act".

    ⚠️This is a teaching document about a made-up case, not a brief filed in a real one and not a ruling: the document's own cover is captioned "IVAN DRAGO, Appellant v. THE STATE OF TEXAS, Appellee", an "Appeal from Stallone County", in "THE FIFTEENTH COURT OF APPEALS", and the arresting officer in its facts is called "Officer Rocky". In it, writing as an Assistant State Prosecuting Attorney and arguing the State's side of that hypothetical, he contends that the smell of marijuana still gives police probable cause to search a vehicle even though hemp smells the same and can lawfully be possessed in some circumstances after the 2019 Texas hemp law.

    Its summary of the argument states that the odor "provided probable cause to search notwithstanding the fact that hemp, which smells the same as marijuana, is legal to possess in a vehicle under limited circumstances", and the argument section states that "Officers have probable cause to search a vehicle for marijuana when they detect the smell of marijuana coming from it." Under the heading "‘Legal’ hemp smells just like illegal marijuana", it states that "The possibility of mistake is irrelevant if that mistake is reasonable."

    The date here is the one its own certificate of service states; the file's embedded modification date is 2022-07-27.

    WeedVoter’s note — shown here, but deliberately left out of the score: Shown but deliberately not scored. This is professional advocacy written in the voice of one party to a hypothetical case, by a government lawyer whose job is to argue the State's side, in a template meant for other prosecutors to reuse. It is not a statement of what he personally thinks the law should be and it is not a vote. Treating it as a campaign position would attribute a policy preference this site cannot establish, so it is recorded for readers and excluded from the arithmetic.

    spa.texas.gov, spa.texas.gov

Holly TaylorDemocrat

No record compiled yet. Nothing on cannabis — no vote, bill, statement or endorsement — was found in any source we could read. One limit on that search is recorded with it.

What was checked for Holly Taylor, and the limits on it

Checked on 2026-09-22: confirmed as a certified candidate in the Secretary of State’s final ballot certification of 28 August 2026. Her campaign site at www.hollytforjudge.com was read (home page) and her San Antonio Report candidate profile at sanantonioreport.org/profile/holly-taylor-2026-candidate-for-texas-criminal-court-of-appeals was read; neither mentions cannabis, marijuana, hemp, THC, CBD or drug policy.

⚠️This card does not tell you whether this candidate held a seat in an earlier Legislature, but the question is now narrower. Read on 2026-10-15, from each chamber’s own journal: the roll of members-elect that the Texas House Journal prints, district by district, on the first day of every regular session from the 75th Legislature (1997) through the 89th (2025), and every senator the Texas Senate Journal names with a district on the first day of every regular session from the 76th (1999) through the 89th.

For the 89th those are journals.house.texas.gov/hjrnl/89r/pdf/89RDAY01FINAL.PDF and journals.senate.texas.gov/SJRNL/89R/HTML/89RSJ01-14-F.HTM and every journal read is listed on this site’s corrections page. No one by this candidate’s name appears in any of them. That is narrower than a negative answer. Those rolls name the members seated as each session opened, and in most years the Senate’s names the senators who were not up for election by surname alone, so a member who sat only in earlier sessions, who arrived at a special election and was never named in full on a later first day, or who served under another name would not be found this way.

If this candidate is one of those, there may be a cannabis voting record this site is missing.

Also checked, and read in full on 2026-10-06: this candidate’s own campaign site at www.hollytforjudge.com — 13 pages taken from the site’s own sitemap.xml (home, Bio, Experience, Why I am Running, Values, Endorsements, the endorsements text page, News and Media, Downloads, Calendar, Tours and the events index), each fetched only after the host’s robots.txt had been checked and found to permit it. Its own pages describe her as "Holly Taylor, Democratic candidate for Judge, Texas CCA, Place 9" (www.hollytforjudge.com/calendar), which is this race.

The fetched pages contain no occurrence, on a word boundary, of cannabis, marijuana, marihuana, hemp, THC, CBD, Compassionate Use, delta-8, delta-9, dispensary, decriminalize, cannabinoid or psilocybin — and that search covered the scripts on those pages as well as their visible text.

This card has been corrected. What an earlier version of it said, and what was wrong with it, is published in the corrections log.

No score: this candidate has no recorded vote or bill authorship on a cannabis measure. Silence is not a position, so nothing is inferred from it.

Campaign sites and voter guides checked for Holly Taylor

Pages read in full:

  • onyourballot.vote411.org/m/race-detail.do?id=71563708 — sections on the page: Qualifications; Ethics; Equity; Precedent; Philosophy — the question set the local League of Women Voters chapter wrote for this race, read in full by us on 2026-10-06. Not one of its questions asks about cannabis, hemp or drug policy. The candidate answered, in free text of their own, and no answer of theirs contains, on a word boundary, cannabis, marijuana, marihuana, hemp, hemp-derived, THC, thc-a, CBD, delta-8, delta-9, cannabinoid, dispensary, decriminalisation, psilocybin, Compassionate Use, consumable hemp, SB 3, Senate Bill 3, HB 1325 or HB 46.
  • www.hollytforjudge.com their own site — sections on the page: the whole of this candidate's own campaign site as this guide read it — 13 pages taken from the site’s own sitemap.xml (home, Bio, Experience, Why I am Running, Values, Endorsements, the endorsements text page, News and Media, Downloads, Calendar, Tours and the events index), each fetched only after the host’s robots.txt had been checked and found to permit it. This row was built on 2026-10-12 out of the sentence above it in this card's own search log, which named the address and said it had been read while the list beside it did not. It records no reading that the log had not already published.

All 2 candidates on this ballot are listed.