No score: the record below carries no direction this site is willing to score — an abstention, a vote on a bill whose effect on legal access is genuinely arguable, or a statement that names no position. It is shown in full so you can read it and judge for yourself.
-
Said2022-07-18
Wrote and signed a model brief that his employer, the State Prosecuting Attorney's office, publishes for prosecutors to adapt, titled on that office's publications page "Model Brief on Hemp Versus Marijuana Smell for Probable Cause to Search a Vehicle Following Texas Hemp Farmgrower's Act".
⚠️This is a teaching document about a made-up case, not a brief filed in a real one and not a ruling: the document's own cover is captioned "IVAN DRAGO, Appellant v. THE STATE OF TEXAS, Appellee", an "Appeal from Stallone County", in "THE FIFTEENTH COURT OF APPEALS", and the arresting officer in its facts is called "Officer Rocky". In it, writing as an Assistant State Prosecuting Attorney and arguing the State's side of that hypothetical, he contends that the smell of marijuana still gives police probable cause to search a vehicle even though hemp smells the same and can lawfully be possessed in some circumstances after the 2019 Texas hemp law.
Its summary of the argument states that the odor "provided probable cause to search notwithstanding the fact that hemp, which smells the same as marijuana, is legal to possess in a vehicle under limited circumstances", and the argument section states that "Officers have probable cause to search a vehicle for marijuana when they detect the smell of marijuana coming from it." Under the heading "‘Legal’ hemp smells just like illegal marijuana", it states that "The possibility of mistake is irrelevant if that mistake is reasonable."
The date here is the one its own certificate of service states; the file's embedded modification date is 2022-07-27.
WeedVoter’s note — shown here, but deliberately left out of the score: Shown but deliberately not scored. This is professional advocacy written in the voice of one party to a hypothetical case, by a government lawyer whose job is to argue the State's side, in a template meant for other prosecutors to reuse. It is not a statement of what he personally thinks the law should be and it is not a vote. Treating it as a campaign position would attribute a policy preference this site cannot establish, so it is recorded for readers and excluded from the arithmetic.